Okay fine. I'm doing it.
After seeing maybe ten people talk about Caro Claire Burke's Yesteryear online, usually holding the book in both hands like an eagle with a fresh kill and often saying something about how UNLIKEABLE and DISGUSTING they thought the protagonist was, I knew I no longer had a choice. I must read this book and judge or join these hateful reviewers.
The story is about a tradwife influencer with a huge subscriber count, an obsessive hatred of "angry women" (her enemies), and an interesting and pragmatically evil view of men, discovering one day that she has awoken in 1855.
"We're only a few souls away from one million on YouTube, Lord."
I'm close to halfway in, and immediately I kind of love Natalie, the insane protagonist. She's written in this wonderfully villianous way, sneering dial turned up to the max and some over-the-top passages about how she blurts out nasty swear words in her head when she talks to God because she seethes so uncontrollably about other women. In some moments, it feels cringy and obvious, but for the most part, I like her Jokerfied persona.
"There comes a point in every marriage when a woman realizes that the man she married is a freak. This is inevitable. It cannot be avoided."
I think the novel is at its best when it lingers in Natalie's mind as she stews in her disdain. In these moments, her chosen lifestyle becomes a means to an end - an exercise in extreme self-control based in an interesting sort of blackpill feminism. She can obtain the best life for herself possible, she thinks, by swallowing down all these things she resents about men, all the little injustices that pepper the lives of women. It's a fun choice to have our tradwife be calculating and sure of her own supremacy, expressing things that many feminists would agree with, but not seeing the connection, too mired in her own individualistic quest for a personal mythology to have any ability to connect with other women.
Natalie is such a fun character. Her bitterness drives her, and there is a wonderful, dark relatability to that - but she is alone, and cocooned in an inescapable misery. Trapped.
I'm excited to finish it soon.




























